A few nights ago, I was walking down the streets of Portland, Maine, listening to a Buddy Holly CD. Iím sure that many of you know that Buddy Holly was one of Jonathanís favorite musicians. During a song called ìEveryday,î which the music therapist had played for him in the ICU, the phrase ìbeautiful soulî came to my mind. Iím sure that anyone who has spent time with Jonathan, from his parents, brother, and family, to his childhood friends, to the nurses who looked over him at the hospital, has had the impression that Jonathan is a beautiful soul. Then I tried to think about what this might mean exactlyówhat is a beautiful soul? And, rather than vague definitions, a few memories come to my mind, which I would like to share with you.
I first met Jonathan on the day of my graduation from Brown in 1994 when Josh and I were roommates; Jonathan was fourteen. I had the flu and had been taking a nap, so I didnít realize that Joshís family (whom I had not yet met) entered our apartment. I came out of my room without my glasses, saw a blurry form in front of me, and said, ìHello, Mrs. Neuman.î After putting on my glasses, I realizedóto my horroróthat I had been addressing Joshís little brother. Instead of rolling his eyes at me and acting like an awkward, exasperated teenager, Jonathan rewarded my mistake with a smile. If you have seen Jonathanís smile, I think youíll understand why I said rewarded. Din had one of the most beautiful, shining smiles I have ever seen, and I was taken with him immediately.
Since that morning in May, I have had the pleasure of seeing Jonathanís smile countless times: when he introduced me to a new punk band, when we discussed our mutual love of horror films, or when we played charades and ate Janetís desserts at New Yearís. There was something genuine about his smileóit was not just a conversation filler or an empty gesture, as our own smiles often are. There was nothing shallow about Jonathanówhatever the circumstance, he had to think about what he was hearing, seeing, or experiencing before he could respond with a smile or a word. Even a simple question like, ìDid you enjoy the meal we just had?,î was met with a long pause as Jonathan thought with great focus and energy about whether that had in fact been an enjoyable meal, an interesting movie, or a good song. When he creased his eyebrows and said, ìYes, I liked it,î I knew he really meant it.
Thatís why I felt sure that Jonathan enjoyed the time he spent visiting me in Maine a year ago with Josh. That visit will always hold an important place in my memories. Jonathan tried to teach me how to skip stones, comforted me while we watched The Exorcist, and told me that the ice cream of Maine was the best he had ever tasted. After it had been blessed by Jonathanís presence and approval, Maine started to feel like home to me.
The last time I saw Jonathan when he was awake was in March, during Passover. We watched some pro-wrestling, listened to the Beatles, and, as always, talked about movies. He asked me to sing him a song, and I told him that the only songs I knew were by Madonna. He said that was okay, encouraged me not to be shy, and sang back-up to my pathetic rendition of ìVogue.î Like the first time I saw him, he didnít roll his eyes at me but made me feel that I was welcome in his world.
Iím an only child, so I didnít know what it was like to have a little brother until I met Jonathan. I want to thank him for that experience, while remaining conscious of the fact that Josh is his true beloved big brother. Still, I am touched to have had the pleasure of being an honorary sister to such a beautiful soul. Thank you, Din. I will always hold you in my heart.